Custom Cake orders need a minimum of 72 hours

If you have a food allergy, please notify us when ordering

Ice Cream Cakes

All ice cream cakes are made with Vanilla & Chocolate ice cream with a chocolate cookie crunch center. Special orders are available with a 3-day advance order. Cakes can also be made with special flavors, and for gluten free, we can fill the center with M & M's or a Strawberry Center, again requiring a minimum of a 3-day advance order.

Just imagine the Creamiest Ice Cream Cake in the world and you have a Seneca Farms Ice Cream Cake!

Our Traditional Ice Cream Cakes are available in the store for immediate pickup made with one layer of Vanilla Custard, a Chocolate Cake Crunch Center with a second layer of Chocolate Custard.

Customized Specialty Cakes include any of our homemade flavors that we currently have in our ice cream shop. 3-day notice required for custom cakes. A few of our most popular combinations are:

A Cookie Themed Cake-

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream, a Chocolate Cake Crunch Center with a second layer of Cookies N Cream Ice Cream.

Strawberry Cheesecake (gluten free)-

Strawberry Ice Cream, a Strawberry Center with a second layer of Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream.

Coffee N Chocolate-

Coffee Ice Cream, with a center of Chocolate Cake crunch plus Cappuccino Candy with a second layer of Chocolate Ice Cream.

Create your OWN! -

These are just 3 of the many, many possibilities! Any of our Homemade flavors along with any fruit, nut, and candy combinations can be put together. What is your favorite Seneca Farms Ice Cream?

Custom Designs Available

Simply stop in and choose a selection from our book. Or if you have a special vision or theme, talk with one of our decorators and we are certain we can create something special just for you. *Pricing is determined based on customization, please inquire beforehand.

We do not take cake orders through email. We are happy to guide you and answer any questions you may have. Cake orders must be done over the phone or in person. Thank you